THE GALLON ENVIRONMENT LETTER
Canadian
Institute for Business and the Environment
Fisherville,
Ontario, Canada
Tel. 416
410-0432, Fax: 416 362-5231
Vol. 14, No. 7, September 25, 2009
Honoured Reader Edition
****************************************************
This is the honoured reader edition of the Gallon Environment Letter and
is distributed at no charge: send a note with Add GL or Delete GL in the
subject line to subscriptions@gallonletter.ca. Subscribers receive a more
complete edition without subscription reminders and with extensive links
to further information following almost every article. Organizational subscriptions
are $184 plus GST nd provide additional benefits detailed on the web site.
Individual subscriptions are only $30 (personal emails/funds only please)
including GST. If you would like to subscribe please visit http://www.cialgroup.com/subscription.htm
If you feel you should be receiving the paid subscriber edition or have
other subscriber questions please contact us also at subscriptions@gallonletter.ca.
This current free edition is posted on the web site about a week or so after
its issue at http://www.cialgroup.com/whatsnew.htm. See also events of external
organizations at http://www.cialgroup.com/events.htm
Back free editions from January 2007 are also available.
***************************************************
ABOUT THIS
ISSUE
Both technology and cities were once seen as
blights on the environment. Today both are often seen as environmental
opportunities and perhaps necessities. “Back to the Land” and neo-Luddism no
longer represent the rallying cry of most environmentally-concerned citizens. In
this issue GL looks at both the role of technology and the role of cities and
finds that, if we are to improve our relationship with the environment, they are
probably both important elements of the future.
A review of a new book by Jeb Brugmann anchors
our look at cities but we are also practical, reviewing our experience of downtown
Detroit, Michigan, USA, earlier this year. If you can have a green city without
people, downtown Detroit probably qualifies.
In an issue that includes some catching up on
items postponed from the last two or three months it is almost inevitable that
we switch to climate change. With the Copenhagen Conference of the parties to
the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change rapidly approaching,
today’s review will likely be the first of several we do in the next three
months. We are also including our review of the paperback edition of Gwynne
Dyer’s new book, Climate Wars, which, in GL’s opinion should be mandatory
reading for Prime Minister Harper and for all those who are still uncertain
about the topic.
As regular readers will recall, GL has been on
a bit of a campaign on the asbestos issue. Against that background a recent US
court decision in favour of W.R. Grace is disappointing, though the jury’s
reasons are interesting. The US EPA has followed up by declaring Libby, Montana,
to be a Public Health Emergency under the Superfund law, the first time anywhere
that this has been done.
Finally this issue catches up on some recent
environmental news: the Niagara Escarpment, a court order against the Minister
of Fisheries and Oceans, a similar order in the US under the Endangered Species
Act, some letters to the Editor, which we always welcome and try to publish,
space permitting, a review of a new book, Good to Green, from John-David
Phyper and Paul Maclean.
We are also listing a job for a senior
sustainable development specialist.
In the next issue we’ll be updating our
coverage of the environmental aspects of nanotechnology. Meanwhile, we hope you
enjoy this one and find it useful.
****************************************************
TECHNOLOGY AND
THE ENVIRONMENT
The relationship between technology and the
environment has been recognized, and somewhat controversial, since the early
days of current concern about the environment. Rachel Carson’s seminal Silent
Spring, published in 1962, was inclined to blame technology for our
environmental troubles. In those days the solutions were seen to be in ‘back to
the land’ and adoption of pre-industrial models of human activity.
By the mid 1980s quite a few industry leaders
were espousing the view that industry, and, by implication, technology, got us
into this mess and that the very same approaches must therefore get us out of
the mess. Such social revolutions as extreme high rise living and electronic
bulletin boards were beginning to reduce our individual environmental footprint.
Today there are widely expressed views that
technology is helping to address environmental risks. Automobile industry and
labour leaders tells us that new cars are far more environmentally friendly than
old cars, the biotechnology industry tells us that genetically modified
organisms can solve the world’s food problems, and the biofuels industry tells
us that their products can solve all our climate challenges, to give just three
examples.
Meanwhile governments do very little to
stimulate greener technology, huge government financial contributions are made
to industries that continue to produce environmentally harmful products, and
Canadian industry steadily falls behind the rest of the developed world when it
comes to manufacture of products that truly help us to reduce our environmental
footprint.
The reality is that there is nothing about new
technology that makes it intrinsically better for the environment. Some new
technologies, such as wind turbines and photovoltaics, do help but others, such
as sport utility vehicles and chlorofluorcarbons, have caused much more harm
than good. In most cases the environmental impact of a new technology depends
far more on how it is used than on what it is. The recent release of DVDs that
you buy and that cease to be playable after 2 days, thus being a sort of virtual
rental that does not need to be returned, is just one of many examples of how
the electronics industry is irresponsibly adding to the world’s garbage problem.
The disposable mop that claims to bring a “whole new meaning” to the process of
cleaning illustrates quite well that corporate environmental irresponsibility,
in the form of increasing the supply of, and demand for, disposable products, is
still alive and well in many sectors.
There are valid arguments that demands for the
elusive perfection must not obstruct the incremental progress that is such an
important part of the evolution of new technologies. Bio-based materials, for
example, are likely to become an environmentally efficient replacement for
fossil and mineral based materials only if we accept the early technology
iterations that are less, or less than, environmentally beneficial. There is
some validity to those arguments, though too many of the transitional materials
come with environmental negatives that could be addressed if industry
consistently applied some more environmentally responsible concepts. Design for
Environment should be as important an element of the development of new
technologies as design for profit.
GL’s editor has always found it difficult to
proof read articles and letters on a computer screen. Schooling with books and
papers seemed to entrench a style of reading that did not fit well with the way
words are presented on a screen. A concerted effort, perhaps assisted by LCD
screens instead of the old television-style monitor, has finally achieved
something of a breakthrough and now I print fewer and fewer documents for
proofreading. Wqhile mistakes still creep in, my newfound ability to proof read
on the monitor has cut office paper consumption quite dramatically.
The same people that bring you Gallon
Environment Letter also publish called Ecological Farming in Ontario. So
far it is a print only magazine, in part because many of Ontario’s farmers have
not yet fully adopted electronic communications - rural internet access is still
slow or expensive in some areas. A future objective is to switch the
magazine to the electronic format. When we do we will save a quarter of a tonne
of paper every year, and that is for just one of Ontario’s small circulation
magazines.
New technology can help us protect the
environment. Protecting the environment can be assisted with new technology. But
new technology is not intrinsically better for the environment and the sooner
government officials and technology developers abandon the theme that new
technology always leads to environmental benefits the sooner we will begin to
put emphasis on properly evaluating what’s good and what’s bad. In the months
ahead, Gallon Environment Letter will be increasing our focus on the good and
the bad of current environmental claims. We invite to you stay with us, and to
offer your thoughts, on what could be quite a wild ride.
Colin Isaacs
Editor
****************************************************
****************************************************
URBANIZATION
OF SOCIETY
In the early days of the modern environmental
movement, in the 1960s and 70s, many felt that the environment could best be
served by dispersing human habitations. This view, that cities were rife with,
and in some ways the cause of, pollution was manifested by the ‘Back to the
Land’ movement. In the 30 or so years since then, most environmentalists have
reversed their perspective. Today the earth clearly cannot support six and a
half billion people living in dispersed settlements. If we are to have enough
land to produce food and raw materials for other goods we must have cities and
by far the majority of people must be housed within them. Interestingly this
trend is taking place, mostly without government law or edict, and, although
many cities still have problems with sprawl, pollution, poverty, and crime,
people, including many environmentally interested people, are now learning how
to live in cities and how to make cities better places to live.
In this issue we look at some of the current
thinking about cities.
****************************************************
BRUGMANN:
WELCOME TO THE URBAN REVOLUTION
Jeb Brugmann is well known for his long
involvement in cities. This past Executive Director of the International Council
for Local Environmental Initiatives contends that "avoiding a crisis on an urban
planet requires that we design cities and their districts as efficient, product
systems governed and managed by communities with strategic purpose." His
recently released book, Welcome to the Urban Revolution, is in some parts heavy
going for those not steeped in the concepts and philosophies of urbanism. The
concepts of "density, scale, association and extension" are rather
abstract.
However, the more concrete content helps to
encourage the reader to put some effort into understanding where Brugmann is
going. Whether cities can ever be sustainable is grist included in
the discussion as Prof. William Rees and others have contended that the
city always has a footprint much larger than its own boundaries.
Brugmann’s statistics help to lure the reader
further into the idea that cities are connected globally to each other and the
whole planet:
In 2006, 150 million global migrants sent
about $300 billion, mostly from foreign cities, back to their home countries.
These "remittances" equal 40% of the total private investment in all developing
countries and dwarf government-supported development funds.
- About one-tenth of the GDP of 43 countries
and about 25% of the GDP of 14 countries is from these migrant money
flows.
- Urban authorities are allowing inadequate
planning and building in high-risk areas. Each year millions of people are
displaced by disasters in urbanized coastline areas. One in eight city
dwellers live in very low coastal areas and 75% of these (about 300 million
people) live in Asia. International development banks spend half of their
funds on emergency and disaster relief.
- Cities are responsible for 70-80% of the
world's energy consumption.
- Construction and demolition: the energy used
to produce and mix concrete releases 5% of the global CO2 emissions.
Construction and demolition waste is generated at the rate of one billion tons
per year. Most of the material is reused changing the landscape within the
city and elsewhere by filling in marsh, building airports, and filling in
waterfronts.
On another rather appealing level, Brugmann
talks about his personal experiences in cities such as Toronto, the Dharavi slum
in Mumbai, and Detroit, He explores issues such as migration, criminal and
illicit activities, ecology and urban design, the role of business - all humans,
organizations, and wildlife seeking advantage in the city and in so doing
creating and recreating it into what sometimes turns out to be a viable city.
Migrants to the city, even those who live in slums, are seen not as victims but
as entrepreneurial risk takers. Some corporations have evolved into longer-term
civic engagement so that the accumulation of wealth for the business also
advances social and economic community interests. Cities are more than markets
and commodities of land and resources.
Brugmann laments the gap between cities'
vision statements and their implementation. He discusses how poorly understood
are the dynamics and strategies needed to create the liveable city. When the
city inhabitants are stymied by the formal city system, they set up parallel
cities of financing, land development including slums, sectarian and criminal
sectors, and enterprise. Brugmann gives examples of Barcelona,
Spain, Curitiba, Brazil, and Chicago, USA as examples of cities which
have transformed decayed and downtrodden communities into "liveable, efficient,
creative agents of global change."
The last part of the book discusses how to
move from cities being a global burden to global solution, outlining a hopeful
trend with the objective being to ensure cities are self-sustaining biomes for
an ever-increasing world population.
Paid subscribers see link to original documents and references here.
****************************************************
MORE CANADIANS
LIVE IN CITIES
The latest Statistics Canada report, Human
Activity and the Environment, discusses food as the feature article and states,
"As the global population increases, the interdependency of food, energy, water,
land and biological resources becomes more apparent."
In 1931, 33% of Canadians lived on farms
compared to only 2% in 2006. While Canada has a large land area, only about 5%
or 47.5 million hectares is suitable for long-term annual crop production. Most
of this is already farmed except for that which has been paved over or built on.
Another 72.4 million hectares is suitable for grassland for grazing livestock
but too marginal for annual crops. Expansion of crops means use of marginal
lands.
Just over 70% of the food bought in Canadian
stores in 2007 was produced domestically. The United States supplies more than
half of imported food, and receives more than half of domestic food exports from
Canada. On average the amount Canadian are spending on food as a portion of
their total income is declining. In 1961 Canadians spent 28% of their personal
expenditures on food compared to 17% in 2007.
In the north, the hinterland of the cities
provides country foods such as caribou, seals, ducks, whales, fish and berries
as part of the tradition of the Inuit. This provides high quality nutrition at
low prices. On the other hand residents of northern isolated communities such as
Repulse Bay, Nunavut and Old Crow, Yukon paid $350-$450 for the Revised Northern
Food Basket. A similar food basket costs $195-225 in southern cities such as
Ottawa and Edmonton.
Statistics Canada. Human Activity and the
Environment: Annual Statistics.
****************************************************
DOWNTOWN
DETROIT: PRIME LOCATION FOR LEASE
Being in downtown Detroit during the annual
Air & Waste Management Association Annual Conference in June was a bit like
seeing one of those science-fiction films where intrepid space travellers return
to Earth and find cities still standing but empty of people. Detroit is, or was,
the auto industry. In Detroit, hundreds of highrise and other buildings, some of
magnificent architecture, are empty: for sale, for lease or just shut. Some are
black with urban soot and broken windows, others look like they just closed
yesterday and still others look like only some floors are in use. One closed
retail store in a whole street of empty businesses improbably displayed a sign
"Opening soon". There was no morning or evening rush hour. Other than a few
clusters of people, mostly not from Detroit Downtown, and some people waiting at
a bus stop, one could walk for several blocks without encountering more than a
handful of people. In contrast, some of the suburban areas are so congested with
traffic that jams are present throughout the day.
NATIONAL
SUMMIT
The silo-like highrise of the General Motors
headquarters and GM's Renaissance Center with stores, restaurants and the
Marriott Hotel dominate the Detroit River front across from the City of Windsor
in Ontario. This was where the Detroit Economic Club hosted the National Summit
featuring CEOs, government people and academics speaking about the economy.
Speakers, panelists and moderators included Canadian Jim Balsillie, Co-CEO of
Research in Motion, The Honourable Perrin Beatty, President and CEO, The
Canadian Chamber of Commerce, Thomas P. d'Aquino; President & CEO, Canadian
Council of Executives; Dr. Jayson Myers, President, Canadian Manufacturers &
Exporters; and Donald J. Walker, Co-CEO, Magna International Inc. Four critical
disciplines – Technology, Energy, Environment and Manufacturing were discussed
in terms of increasing America's competitiveness. A report is expected to be
released within some months. The summit leaders apparently took a less
conspicuous consumption approach including taking taxis and riding the
PeopleMover (see below) rather than being driven to dinner in big
limos.
Protestors, part of the People's Summit with
speaker Rev. Jesse Jackson expressed their views that the government should be
bailing out the poor people not the rich ones, that auto plant closures and lack
of a living wage and healthcare was causing suffering of ordinary people and
workers. The police guarded the entrance to GM HQ where a large fancy sign read
GM NEXT.
URBAN CENTER
LIGHT RAIL
We rode in the Detroit PeopleMover, an
elevated, single track, electric automated (no driver) train which circles in
one direction almost five kilometres through the what-used-be central business
and shopping district, stopping at 13 stations connecting to restaurants, arena,
conference center, casino, hotels and the banking centres. It is Canadian
technology made by Bombardier, the same as Vancouver's Skytrain and opened in
1987. There are no transfers to buses. Each train has two cars and in the half
dozen times we rode it, there were either no other people or no more than three
other riders. Detroit is known for its high rates of poverty and unemployment so
some say the transit may be misnamed. The Rich Folk's Roller Coaster has been
suggested because of its low ridership (it doesn't move very many people) and a
good portion of the riders are out-of-towners on weekend visits or attending
events They are subsidized by the residents because the fare of 50 cents pays
only a small part of the operation. For us subsidized visitors, however, it
provided an easy way of spreading our money around to do purchasing from what
felt like more local vendors, a number of which were clustered quite close to
the stops for the transit compared to the conference hotel area. The view of the
city is great.
GREEN
SHOOTS
While the top executives were looking for
economic green shoots, greening Detroit is very noticeable in the downtown core
with garden squares and trees. The mature trees have mostly been decimated by
Dutch Elm Disease and emerald ash borer. The newer trees are often planted in
groups of at least three in quite large strips with shrubs growing underneath.
The trees are much more likely to survive under such conditions than when they
are planted singly completely surrounded by cement. The visual effect of
greenery is noticeable and pleasant. The non-profit group Greening of Detroit is
promoting urban forestry, community gardens to combat hunger and increase food
security, environmental education for school children and opening a nursery to
grow the trees for planting in the city. According to the group, originally
youth were employed through their Green Corps program, but adults have been
employed since 2007 as well, "Through this expanded Green Corps Employment
program, we provide Detroiters of all ages with on-the-job training in the Green
Industry, including hands-on experience at The Greening's large-scale
restoration plantings, tree nursery program and vacant lot cleaning and
reclamation programs."
Paid subscribers see link to original documents and references here.
****************************************************
COPENHAGEN:
CLIMATE CHANGE CONFERENCE
A new global climate treaty may not be agreed
to in detail in Copenhagen but back in March, UN climate chief Yvo de Boer
recommended that an international agreement to succeed the Kyoto Protocol should
at least answer 4 questions:
1. How much are the industrialized countries
willing to reduce their emissions of greenhouse gases?
2. How much are major developing countries
such as China and India willing to do to limit the growth of their
emissions?
3. How is the help needed by developing
countries to engage in reducing their emissions and adapting to the impacts of
climate change going to be financed?
4. How is that money going to be managed?
Businesses around the world are making long
term investments in power plants, buildings and technologies and need some
clarification of government intentions.
Paid subscribers see link to original documents and references here.
****************************************************
DANISH
CLEANTECH
Danish business activities at the UN Climate
Change Conference to be held in Copenhagen December 7 - December 18 will be
carried under the banner of the Climate Consortium Denmark. A web-based guide
showcases cleantech suppliers and solutions. It is intended to be useful
to
- researchers looking for partners or new
results in emerging energy technologies
- investors looking for opportunities in
emerging climate technologies or solutions
- politicians or civil servants looking for
information on how to implement sustainable energy systems
- journalists looking for ideas, cases,
statistics and facts for their next article on the climate change issue
and
- companies looking for carbon-reducing
technologies.
Both the private and public sector have been
improving energy products and processes in the last decade. Danish export of
energy technology and equipment tripled in the last decade and outperformed all
other Danish export. Denmark markets itself as a leader in wind energy, which
contributes 6.5% of total Danish exports. Danish trade councils and embassies
are promoting Danish cleantech solutions. Of the 17 target markets, Canada is
one.
EnergyTours has been set up with the national
tourism organization so top management, technical management and commercial
management of leading energy companies and developers, technology providers and
consulting engineers as well as politicians and administrations can visit sites,
demonstration facilities and hold face to face meeting with Danish company
leaders.
The EnergyTours have environmental features of
their own: EURO5 engines in buses or particle filters, flights from around the
world to Denmark via Lufthansa*, certified green hotels and conference
facilities. the Carlson Wagonlit Travel, the business travel management company,
provides the CWT Sustainable Solutions with carbon calculator, post-trip
emissions management reporting and services to reduce carbon dioxide emissions.
The Government of Denmark is a strategic partner
Paid subscribers see link to original documents and references here.
****************************************************
CLIMATE
WARS
If you haven't read Climate Wars by Gwynne
Dyer as part of your non-fiction summer reading, the paperback edition has been
released. If you weren't alarmed before about global warming, it will give you a
jolt especially the scenarios of the future e.g. China 2042 and Wipeout. It is
mighty fine writing and credible. Dyer himself interviewed many of the people he
quotes including James Lovelock famed for the concept of earth as Gaia, Vandana
Shiva in India known for award-winning leadership on women and ecology in
development and James Hansen, director NASA Goddard Space Station.
It is a deeply pessimistic companion piece to
Brugmann's more optimistic Welcome to the Urban Revolution (see separate
article) in that there is a lot of discussion of global impacts of what humanity
is doing: population, food, consumption, fossil fuels, and political
decision-making. Scenarios include migration explored by Brugmann but here that
topic is detailed on what could happen when coastal cities are flooded and
refugees from those flooded cities become migrants to above-the-flood
settlements. Conflicts and war are predicted outcomes.
Dyer sees it as unlikely that the US
administration will implement 80% cuts in greenhouse gas emissions by 2030,
"With luck, they might aim to do half of that - in which case, we can look
forward to only about half of the calamities that a complete failure to respond
to the problem would entail. And then, in due course, some of those calamities
will motivate us to make deeper cuts-although coming later, they will be of less
use. And so on. It is probably going to be a long, miserable experience, with an
uncertain outcome."
Gwynne
Dyer
According to the book’s web site, "Gwynne Dyer
has served in the Canadian, British and American navies. He holds a Ph.D. in war
studies from the University of London, has taught at Sandhurst and served on the
Board of Governors of Canada’s Royal Military College. Dyer writes a syndicated
column that appears in more than 175 newspapers around the
world." GL’s editor adds that while Gwynne Dyer has a
lot of credibility as a columnist and commentator with millions of people around
the world it is unlikely that his words would have much resonance with Prime
Minister Harper. What a pity!
Paid subscribers see link to original documents and references here.
****************************************************
LIBBY,
MONTANA: ENVIRONMENTAL CRIME
Sometimes it is surprising how long it takes
for society to take basic steps to achieve social justice and environmental
protection. In Canada, this is only the 35th year (1974) since our national
police the RCMP accepted female officers. Among a number of reasons a US jury
dismissed the case against W.R. Grace earlier this year despite the deaths
caused by the hazardous release of asbestos in the town of Libby, Montana was
that it was only in 1990, that the US Clean Air Act was amended to make it a
crime to release a hazardous substance with the knowledge that it could cause
death or serious injury. The mine closed in 1990 and some of the defendants
charged had left the company by then. On May 8, the jury in the courtroom of
U.S. District Judge Donald Molloy in Missoula, Montana acquitted W.R. Grace
& Co. and three of its former executives of all crimes associated with the
abnormally high rate of death and disease due to asbestos in Libby,
Montana.
Public Health
Emergency
In June, Lisa Jackson, Administrator of the US
Environmental Protection Agency declared a public health emergency under
Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA or
Superfund) at the Libby asbestos site, which includes the towns of Libby and
Troy. Libby is seven miles from the inactive vermiculite mine. The mine supplied
80% of the world's vermiculite while it was operating. Vermiculite was used for
insulating buildings and as a soil amendment but was contaminated with asbestos.
Many in the community with no association with the mine were exposed to
asbestos. The soil, the water, the dust, and the sediment were contaminated.
Roads, public parks, gardens, homes indoors were contaminated. Disease and
death-causing exposure was mostl59through inhalation. Even if the town itself
hadn't been polluted with direct application of asbestos via the
vermiculite, the air from the mine was transporting asbestos into the town. This
is the first time EPA has issued a Public Health Emergency determination under
the Superfund law in its history. While the EPA has been "cleaning up" e.g.
excavating soil and replacing it with non-contaminated soil, of the over 4000
home/commercial places, over 800 haven't been inspected yet and only 1100 have
been cleaned with an expectation of cleaning about 100 more buildings and spaces
in 2009. The public places such as parks where vermiculite was spread were done
first. The emergency declaration is more for funding health care for the sick
people.
Paid subscribers see link to original documents and references here.
****************************************************
NIAGARA
ESCARPMENT
Robert Patrick, President of the Coalition on
the Niagara Escarpment CONE sent along a copy of the latest newsletter (June
2009) which is issued several times a year. CONE is a non-profit alliance of
environmental groups, conservation organizations, and concerned citizens and
businesses founded in 1978 and dedicated to the protection of Ontario’s Niagara
Escarpment.
One article describes the history of the
non-governmental effort to protect this unique land. Originally unorganized,
"the noisy but passionate rabble" persuaded then Ontario Premier Bill Davis and
his minority Progressive Conservative government to prevent repeal of a law
restricting commercial activity and development of the Niagara Escarpment.
Ontario Nature (then Federation of Ontario Naturalist) thought a coalition would
be more organized to protect the 725-kilometre escarpment with a number of
unique ecosystems. The group has fought many battles. One of the founding
members GL mentioned in the last issue is John Willms, an environmental lawyer
who helped advise on potential legal battles.
The pressures for aggregate and development
continue. Part of the Escarpment is located in the Golden Horseshoe which
stretches along the west coast of Lake Ontario from Niagara Falls and is the
heaviest populated and urbanized region in Canada (8.1 million people,
two-thirds of Ontarians and one-quarter of all Canadians). The Province of
Ontario has designated the Greenbelt to protect natural and farm lands, but some
development is leapfrogging beyond those greenbelt boundaries to continue the
sprawl. onto very high quality farmland which could produce those luscious
peaches and other fruit which we here in southern Ontario take for granted.
Control of agricultural land severance and the provincial policy Places to Grow
is requiring cities to set specified targets for density before they can expand
beyond their boundaries and is forcing welcome change in city sprawl. But a lot
of land is grandfathered and in the hands of developers and an amazing number of
houses and developments are springing up. And just the sheer number of people
put pressure on natural landscapes such as the treasure of the Niagara
Escarpment.
Coalition on the Niagara Escarpment.
Newsletter. June 2009.
****************************************************
WHAT A
DIFFERENCE A LITTLE FISH (SPECIES) MAKES
The freshwater Nooksack dace used to be common
in BC and Washington State but began to disappear, according to Fisheries and
Oceans Canada, "as a result of construction, development and other human
activities." In Canada, drought leads to lack of water for them and in the US,
creeks are filling with silt. The Species at Risk Act SARA and the stewardship
activities since the 1990s was supposed to prevent the extinction of this small
shallow water fish.
The environmental groups Environmental Defence
Canada, Georgia Strait Alliance, Western Canada Wilderness Committee, and the
David Suzuki Foundation sued the Minister of Fisheries and Oceans. The
applicants contended that "The Applicants argue that the Minister knowingly
failed to follow the mandatory requirements of s. 41(1)©) and ©.1) of SARA with
respect to the Final Recovery Strategy for the Nooksack Dace." Justice Campbell
of the Canada's Federal Court agreed, "This is a story about the creation and
application of policy by the Minister in clear contravention of the law, and a
reluctance to be held accountable for failure to follow the law. ... I find that
the Minister acted contrary to the law intended by Parliament to protect the
Nooksack Dace." Ministers of the Crown have to comply with the rule of law.
The Recovery Team had identified critical
habitat as required under the legislation but when the final plan was posted no
critical habitat was identified in the Recovery Strategy at the direction of the
Minister and/or his delegate. The law requires that once the Minister determines
that the recovery of a listed species is feasible then the recovery plan must
include among other specifications the critical habitat of the species and where
identification of critical habitat is inadequate a schedule of studies to
identify critical habitat. "Critical habitat" means the habitat that is
necessary for the survival or recovery of a listed wildlife species.
The reason the identification of critical
habitat is so important is that this identification kicks off the protective
measures of SARA. Water withdrawal, toxicity from urban storm drainage, channel
dredging, and removal or reduction in stream-side vegetation have reduced the
population of the little fish. Insects landing on the vegetation fall into the
water and are an important food source. Vegetation also prevent toxics and
sediments from entering the stream.
The Wilderness Committee says that the same
unlawful policy has been applied to 17 other species in British Columbia which
will have to have their recovery plans rewritten. The change could affect many
things including the development of cities to ensure the species critical
habitat is adequately protected.
Paid subscribers see link to original documents and references here.
****************************************************
ANOTHER LITTLE
FISH CAUSES RETHINK IN WATER POLICY IN CALIFORNIA
A ruling in the US on another very small fish
known as the delta smelt designated under the US Endangered Species Act also
slapped down a US federal Fish and Wildlife position. Justice Oliver Wanger in
the US Federal District Court restricted the pumping of water from the
Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta to southern California to leave enough water to
protect the fish. Counter litigation has delayed some of the restrictions but
are pushing California and other drought-affected states to work harder on water
management. Fishing associations say that the ruling isn't just human vs tiny
fish but that protecting that little fish also protects salmon and other
commercial fish species. The salmon are trying to return to spawning grounds,
rivers which have dried up. The delta smelt ruling has been a wake-up call and
set up a farm vs cities debate (who will get priority for the limited
water).
Paid subscribers see link to original documents and references here.
****************************************************
LETTERS TO THE
EDITOR
Subject:
Gallon Environment Letter v14 n6 Honoured Reader Edition
Hey, I just wanted to say, really good letter
this time around. Exactly the issues I have been debating with my friends - why
and how Canada is missing the opportunity to make the shift to the New Green
Economy, with renewable energy at the forefront.
Keep up the good work.
Matt Woods
Kenya
***
Subject:
Gallon Environment Letter Vol. 14 No. 06 August 18, 2009
Dear Colin,
This edition is a superb summary of the state
of renewable energy knowledge, policy, potential and pitfalls. I am currently
working on a film (due out by November, I hope) which makes the nexus between
our energy choices and the state of democracy, community and public
participation it's central focus. I am thrilled with many aspects of Ontario's
Green Energy Act, but very concerned by the perceived need to run roughshod over
established environmental and social safeguard mechanisms for the sake of green
energy. What I call the "bully" approach is never the best one, whether for
nuclear, fossil or renewable energy.
This issue will be helpful to me as I complete
the scriptwriting and start the editing in earnest this month. I look forward to
being able to share details of my film Powerful: Energy for Everyone soon,
perhaps for your next issue. In the meantime though, your readers can view the
trailer and a whole host of videos taken from the film here: http://www.livinglightly.ca/powerful/
Regards,
David
David Chernushenko
Green economy educator / Living Lightly
pathfinder / Speaking • Visual media production • Current affairs analysis
613-730-0870 david///davidc.ca [replace to send email] http://www.davidc.ca
Producer/Director: Be the Change
***
Subject:
Gallon Environment Letter Vol. 14 No. 06 August 18, 2009
This is just to say that it is one of the best
ever. Nicely balanced but clearly positive in favour of renewables. And thank
you for the note about the water-energy nexus. Few people are aware of how much
energy it takes to pump water, to say nothing of how much water it takes to
produce the energy to pump water.
One sidelight for your amusement re tidal
power -- in the category of unexpected effects. When the tidal power station was
built in the 1980s, the engineers designed it carefully so the turbines would
not injure fish. They could get caught in the system, but, being streamlined by
nature, they would simply emerge at the other side; hence no adverse
environmental effect. The engineering-environmental analysis was right so far as
it went. The fish do go through the turbines unharmed, but, to no surprise once
you think about it, they come out dizzy. When a fish is dizzy, it floats to the
top, and out there, just waiting for this bonanza, is every fish-eating bird in
the Maritimes. United Birds of the Maritimes is now 100% in favour of more tidal
projects, though they have also applied for a government grant to study obesity
in fish-eating species.
Best wishes,
David
David Brooks
GL Note1: Nova Scotia announced approval of
the Bay of Fundy tidal project.
GL Note2: David's new book on water soft paths
is coming out this month:
David B. Brooks, Oliver M. Brandes and Stephen
Gurman (editors), Making the Most of the Water We Have: The Soft Path Approach
to Water Management (London, UK: Earthscan, 2009); C$115 http://www.earthscan.co.uk/?tabid=74750
****************************************************
THIRTY SECOND
SUMMARY
Kelly Hawke Baxter, Executive Director, The
Natural Step Canada sent a general emailing about new Toolkits for
Sustainability about best practices available free on the their website. TNS
acknowledges the generous support of the Alberta Real Estate Foundation, the
Calgary Foundation and the J.W. McConnell Family Foundation for making these
toolkits possible. The organization also offers 2-day sustainability training
for leaders across Canada this fall as well as a 5 month course in community
planning towards sustainability. http://www.thenaturalstep.org/canada
The Natural Step Canada 355 Waverley Street
Ottawa, Ontario Canada K2P 0W4 info////naturalstep.ca (replace to send
email)
***
Art means business according to Americans for
the Arts, an organization promoting art in schools and in communities. In 2007,
the nonprofit arts and culture industry generated $166.2 billion and 5.7 million
jobs. In June, the national annual conference held in Seattle focussed on the
sustainability of the arts sector and the role of culture and art in sustainable
communities. One of the speakers on the Public Art Track was Canadian artist
Sarah Hall.
In 2006, Hall created the art glass for the
wind tower at Theology Library of the Regent College in Vancouver. It was the
first installation of photovoltaic art glass in North America. The solar cells
are sandwiched between two panes of glass so the window is double-glazed for
extra insulation. Clive Grout, the architect designed the tower which provides
natural ventilation to the underground library which is covered by a park in
honour of the College's commitment to ecology and environmental stewardship. In
April Hall and Grout were awarded the Design Merit Award for Sacred Landscapes
from the American Institute of Architects (AIA).
Pioneering UBC Windows Provide Solar Energy: A
New Partnership With The Sun Begins September 29, 2007.
Canadian Solar Industries Association.
Vancouver’s Solar Tower Sparks American Institute of Architects
Award.
****************************************************
IISD: GLOBAL
SEARCH FOR CEO AND PRESIDENT
The International Institute for Sustainable
Development IISD is an independent, non-profit policy research institute
headquartered in Winnipeg, Manitoba communicating on sustainable development
with an annual budget around $15 million and 110 staff and associates. Other
offices are in Ottawa, New York and Geneva. IISD is looking for a full-time
innovative and energetic President & CEO to continue the growth and
expansion of the last 20 years and to implement the new five-year strategic
plan. Compensation arrangements will be comparable with other similar
international non-profit organizations.
Applicants should forward a cover letter and
curriculum vitae by e-mail to Stephanie Cairns, Wrangellia Consulting, at
iisdsearch//wrangellia.ca (replace to send email) by September 30,
2009.
IISD's head office 161 Portage Avenue East,
6th Floor Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada R3B 0Y4 tel: 204 958-7700
Ottawa office (new address, effective October
5, 2009) 75 Albert Street, Suite 903 Ottawa,
Ontario Canada K1P 5E7 tel: +1 613 238-2296
David
Runnalls
David Runnalls is the current President &
Chief Executive Officer with a long history of involvement with sustainable
development, environmental and conservation groups, business and international
organizations. For example, he is a member of the Advisory Council for Export
Development Canada, the Council for Sustainable Development Technology Canada,
the Ivey Business School Leadership Council and is on the Inquiry Team for
Tomorrow’s Global Company, the SAM/SPG Leadership award, the International
Sustainability Innovation Council of Switzerland (ISIS), and the Shell Report
External Review Committee. As well as being a Canadian board member of the
IUCN-the World Conservation Union for six years, he was a board member of the
World Environment Center (New York), IIED (London) and Pollution Probe
(Toronto). One issue of the GL would be too small to list his many contributions
to the field of sustainability.
Paid subscribers see link to original documents
and references here.
****************************************************
****************************************************
BOOK: GOOD TO
GREEN
There are environmental books for business on
overall strategies and on specific themes. Good to Green by Canadians,
John-David Phyper and Paul Maclean has larger ambition: to bridge a whole range
of topics on business practices as well as environmental group positions,
government regulations and emerging sustainability trends. That's a whole lot
for anybody to write about and for the reader to chew but the book may be a
useful tool for business people and others wanting to view a range of
environment and sustainability issues and how these are potentially changing and
impacting business.
The authors sent various drafts and chapters
to people practising in the environmental area for comment including GL's
editor, who doesn't necessarily agree with some of their conclusions (nothing
new there for anybody who reads GL regularly). GL has no argument with their
view that companies ought to "dig deeper" to develop understanding of the risks
and opportunities of environmental issues in order to ensure "these issues [can]
be properly managed at the strategic, tactical and operational level" although
GL wants to ensure that companies realize that it is not just about business but
also about the environment and social sustainability.
The authors call it "cosmetic
environmentalism" when companies pick "easy to do things" such as recycling
programs at Head Office; Recycling isn't in the book's index. However, to GL,
recycling is basic, not cosmetic or aesthetic and no different than requiring
doctors to wash their hands, which may be mundane and simple but is also
essential as the growing concern about medically-caused infection indicates. If
a company has little experience in environmental management, picking the
low-hanging fruit, ie the easy things, is often a good place to start but hardly
is a reason for boasting. Nevertheless, the value of the book, whether the
reader agrees or not with the viewpoints expressed, may be more in the broader
world of environmental concepts, trends, examples/cases and initiatives
presented.
The chapter on executing a green strategic
plan lists some of the costs to companies who fail to take environmental issues
into account and describes CEO leadership at Walmart, GE, DuPont, Virgin Group,
Khosla Venture, Tesla, Google and Project Better Place. And goes on from there
to explore sample Sustainable Development Policies (Bayer) and Corporate Social
Responsibility Policy (Enbridge), a discussion on long-term value to
shareholders and key market influencers. That's just a small part of the chapter
which also includes a discussion of the risk and opportunities of adopting
greening strategies.
In total, the book includes nine chapters
covering design, green marketing, environmental management systems, supply chain
drivers, alternatives to petroleum, emissions trading, human resources, and a
road map for the future and lots and lots of references. Case studies of some of
the big companies show how they are implementing some of the concepts and
strategies.
The book could use some polishing, for example
GL found a number of the graphs and illustrations difficult to read because of a
dark background combined with black or grey ink and somewhat obscure. Also one
has to flip the book too often to read sideways. It would also be good to learn
a bit more of small and medium-sized business initiatives rather than so much of
the mega-corporations. And the book could use a bit more to the authors’ voices,
those personal voices of experience which would help to increase credibility
about the advice such as those at the end of each chapter: the take-aways. There
is lots of advice. One favourite of GL's is "Build it and they might not come"
which illustrates that the commonly-held belief that green products, technology
and services will inherently and automatically be successful in the marketplace
is often a myth.
A book such as this can choose important
trends from all that news coming at us everyday and summarize key points for
further thought by the reader. Perhaps we’ll see a Good to Green 2010 or 2011
with more corporate initiatives and approaches, consumer trends and changing
government policies and regulations.
****************************************************
****************************************************
ONTARIO
SHOWCASE AT AWMA ANNUAL CONFERENCE
Five Ontario environmental companies and the
Ontario Centres of Excellence were participants in an Ontario Showcase at the
annual conference and trade show of the Air & Waste Management Association
held in Detroit, Michigan June 16-19. The showcase was organized by the Ontario
Ministry of International Trade and Investment specifically by Marek Karwowski,
Area Director - US Automotive, Construction & Environment
Sectors.
Each company paid for its share of what would
have been three booths but which was cheaper for each participant due to the
extra number of companies sharing the space. Each company provided its own
people although for those who came alone, Karwowski offered an hour or so of
booth duty for each - several days of promoting your business at a trade show
booth can be wearing and requires a break at least at mealtimes.
Instead of a booklet which is often printed
for trade shows for Ontario Delegations, Karwowski made a small third-of-a-page
double-sided leaflet which he thought was more environmentally preferable. GL
notes that fewer people seem to pick up a lot of leaflets at trade shows but
rather prefer to pick up business cards and check out the links on the web sites
- a lesson for those of us who don't keep our web sites as up to date as we
should.
Both Karwowski and Balinder Rai, Manager of
Business Development at the Ontario Centres of Excellence did networking to link
up potential business partners. If you are an Ontario company involved in
environmental business, you would do well to get on the mailing lists of these
two people. Both demonstrate, "I'm from the government and I'm here to help you"
can actually be true.
The five companies were:
Altech Technology Systems Inc.
12 Banigan Dr Toronto Ontario M4H
1E9
Contact: George Bennett Director Business
Development
tel: 416 467-5555 x243 email:
gbennett//altech-group.com
Designs, develops and manufactures technology
for air pollution abatement, industrial wastewater treatment and customized
solutions such as controlling odours. Has Canadian and US license for System
REITHER(TM) for controlling particulate, aerosols, acid mists and odorous
gases.
CIAL Group, the parent company of the Gallon
Environment Letter
Development of sustainability strategies for
business. Clients in manufacturing, processing and distribution. Toolkit
includes lifecycle analysis, cleaner production, pollution prevention, corporate
and social responsibility reporting, environmental information systems,
environmental management, climate strategies, and environmental finance access
information.
HYGREX (TM) Technologies Inc
1040 Martin Grove Rd Unit 18 Toronto Ontario
M9W 4W4
Contact: Erwin Spehr, President and Eder Leon
Sales/Export
A patented air dry technology Super Dry Air
eliminates the needs for exhaust vents and emission permits for industrial
drying applications such as water or solvent paint drying, food processing,
automotive applications, and waste management.
Macrotek Inc
4-400 Bentley St Markham Ontario L3R
8H6
Contact: Tom Payne , President
Designs and supplies air pollution control
systems including scrubbers, dust collectors, mist eliminators and exhaust
stacks. Specialize in complete integrated systems with instrumentation and
controls. Technologies include annular throat venturi scrubber, powder injection
dry scrubber, packed tower and spray tower scrubbers.
Riva Modelling
RB2-530 Richmond St West Toronto Ontario M5V
1Y4
Contact: Evan Liske, Account
Manager
Has a fully configurable web-based software
tool to perform strategic long range asset, risk and budget management by
forecasting the full lifecycle of the assets including municipal roads,
corporate buildings, etc
Ontario Centres of Excellence for Earth and
Environmental Technologies
156 Front St. Suite 200 Toronto Ontario M5J
2L6
Contact: Balinder Rai Manager Business
Development
The Centre of Excellence for Earth and
Environmental Technologies is one of a number of Centres of Excellence supplies
innovation and commercialization services, offered in partnership with Ontario's
university and college community to help Ontario organizations compete by
adopting innovative, environmentally responsible solutions. The Centre
co-invests in the research and development of leading-edge, industrially
relevant technologies and develops the team – partners and resources – required
to deliver innovative solutions, including the recent graduates and young
innovators who make organizations more competitive.
The Ontario Showcase was presented and hosted
by
Ministry of International Trade and
Investment
International Trade Branch
6th Floor, Hearst Block 900 Bay Street Toronto
Ontario M7A 2E1
Contact: Marek Karwowski, Area Director - US
Automotive, Construction & Environment Sectors tel: 416 325-9210 email:
marek.karwowski//ontario.ca web: http://www.ontarioexports.com
****************************************************
TO WHOM DOES
THIS CORPORATE SLOGAN REFER?
Berlin-based SOLON SE, a manufacturer of solar
modules and systems, says it is the first German solar company; its initial
public offering was in 1998. Its corporate slogan, proudly displayed at the top
of its web page, is ‘Don’t leave the planet to the stupid’. GL cannot help but
wonder to whom this slogan is directed.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Copyright © Canadian Institute for Business
and the Environment
119 Concession 6 Rd Fisherville ON N0A 1GO
Canada. Fisherville & Toronto
All rights reserved. The Gallon Environment
Letter (GL for short) presents information for general interest and does not
endorse products, companies or practices. Information including articles,
letters and guest columns may be from sources expressing opinions not shared by
the Canadian Institute for Business and the Environment. Readers must verify all
information for themselves before acting on it. Advertising or sponsorship of
one or more issues consistent with sustainable development goals is welcome and
identified as separate from editorial content. Subscriptions for organizations
$184 + GST = $193.20. For individuals (non-organizational emails and paid with
non-org funds please) $30 includes GST. Issues about twelve times a year with
supplements. http://www.cialgroup.com/subscription.htm
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx